ChemWiki

username password

Halogenation of Benzene-The Need for a Catalyst

    Halogenation is an example of electrophillic aromatic substitution. In electrophilic aromatic substitutions, a benzene is attacked by an electrophile which results in substition of hydrogens. However, halogens are not electrophillic enough to break the aromaticity of benzenes, which require a catalyst to activate.

    Activation of Halogen

    (where X= Br or Cl, we will discuss further in detail later why other members of the halogen family Flourine and Iodine are not used in halogenation of benzenes)

    no reaction (2).jpg

    Hence, Halogen needs the help and aid of Lewis Acidic Catalysts to activate it to become a very strong electrophile. Examples of these activated halogens are Ferric Hallides (FeX3) Aluminum Halides (AlX3) where X= Br or Cl. In the following examples, the halogen we will look at is Bromine.

    In the example of bromine, in order to make bromine electrophillic enough to react with benzene, we use the aid of an aluminum halide such as aluminum bromide.

    AlBr3.jpg

    With aluminum bromide as a Lewis acid, we can mix Brwith AlBr3 to give us Br+. The presence of Br+ is a much better electrophile than Br2 alone.

    Bromination is acheived with the help of AlBr3 (Lewis acid catalysts) as it polarizes the Br-Br bond. The polarization causes polarization causes the bromine atoms within the Br-Br bond to become more electrophillic. The presence of Br+ compared to Br2 alone is a much better electrophille that can then react with benzene.

    electrophile (2).jpg

    As the bromine has now become more electrophillic after activation of a catalyst, an electrophillic attack by the benzene occurs  at the terminal bromine of Br-Br-AlBr3. This allows the other bromine atom to leave with the AlBras a good leaving group, AlBr4-.

    nuc (2).jpg

    Benzene Brominationfinal (1).jpg

    After the electrophilic attack of bromide to the benzene, the hydrogen on the same carbon as bromine substitutes the carbocation in which resulted from the attack. Hence it being an electrophilic aromatic SUBSTITUTION. Since the by-product aluminum tetrabromide is a strong nucleophile,  it pulls of a proton from the Hydrogen on the same carbon as bromine.

    end copy (1).jpg

    In the end, AlBr3 was not consumed by the reaction and is regenerated. It serves as our catalyst in the halogenation of benzenes.

    Dissociation Energies of Halogens and its Effect on Halogenation of Benzenes

    The electrophillic bromination of benzenes is an exothermic reaction. Considering the exothermic rates of aromatic halogenation decreasing down the periodic table in the Halogen family, Flourination is the most exothermic and Iodination would be the least. Being so exothermic, a reaction of flourine with benzene is explosive! For iodine, electrophillic iodination is generally endothermic, hence a reaction is often not possible. Similar to bromide, chlorination would require the aid of an activating presence such as Alumnium Chloride or Ferric Chloride. The mechanism of this reaction is the same as with Bromination of benzene. 

    References

    1. Vollhardt, Peter, and Neil Shore. Organic Chemistry: Structure and Function. 5th Edition. New York: W.H. Freeman and Company, 2007.

    Problems

    1. What reagents would you need to get the given product?

     

    practice 1.jpg

     2. What product would result from the given reagents?

    practice 2.jpg

    3. What is the major product given the reagents below? 

    practice 3.jpg

    4. Draw the formatin of Cl+ from AlCland Cl2

    5. Draw the mechanism of the reaction between Cl+ and a benzene.

     

    Solutions

    1. Cland AlCl3 or Cl2 and FeCl3

    2. No Reaction

    3.

    answer 3.jpg

    4.

    alcl3.jpg

    5.

    answer 4.jpg

    ContributorsEdit section

    • Catherine Nguyen

    This page viewed 30203 times
    The ChemWiki has 9262 Modules.

     

    Creative Commons 
License    UC Davis ChemWiki by University of California, Davis is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 United States License
    Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available at copyright@ucdavis.edu. Terms of Use
    Powered by Mindtouch Core 2010

    Viewing 4 of 4 comments: view all
    hey! I see you have really given a good outline of halogenation. it might be worthwhile though to explain that some halogens will not react at all with benzene. for instance, you could replace your Bromine with an X to represent the halogens and then say "where X=Br2, Cl2" or something like that...also be sure to mention that your solution will be different with the type of halogen you want to react the benzene with.
    Posted 13:07, 2 Mar 2009
    Good job! My section also involved benzene rings and I know how hard it is to make images for that, so I can really appreciate how nice your mechanisms turned out. I really like that you included the reasons for why only Br2 and Cl2 go through this reaction, no one really explained that to me. Even though you mentioned that Cl2 goes through the same process as Br2, I think your module focuses on Br2 more than Cl2. Perhaps you ought to add in a small example of Cl2? It might make your practice problems more doable since the majority are on Cl2, but your examples on Br2. Also, including the resonance structures in the carbocationic stage would be good- I know our professor expects us to draw them on the test so having them here would be a good reminder that they exist!
    Posted 13:45, 7 Mar 2009
    Good job! You did a really good job of working up to the explanation of why you need a Lewis Acid catalyst...In that first paragraph I think adding a hyperlink to aromaticity or the stability of benzene would be a good addition...The pictures looked good, the only problem I had with them was that in a couple of them the writing was a bit small, so it was kind of hard to read, also a few of the pictures came in fairly fuzzy...I think it would be helpful to add in a section about the application of these reactions if possible...I also agree with the previous statement and think that drawing in the resonance forms would be helpful for the reader...I also think you need to add in more references besides the textbook, try looking at some journals or something...
    Posted 18:08, 7 Mar 2009
    Terrific module! I especially enjoy your beginning surprise figure of "no reaction," as well as your extremely clear and concise explanation of why this reaction only works with bromine and chlorine. I like how your mechanism arrows are in a different color as well.
    However, I am still a bit unclear on what exactly an "activated halogen" is or why it is called that. Does this reaction work with substituted benzenes (as in CH3-benzene, etc.). Also, you should try to include more on carbocation shifts (if any) as well as links to other ChemWiki modules to help tie in your module with the entire site. edited 22:15, 8 Mar 2009
    Posted 21:15, 8 Mar 2009
    Viewing 4 of 4 comments: view all
    You must login to post a comment.
    FileSizeDateAttached by 
     AlBr3.jpg
    No description
    26.72 kB01:13, 2 Mar 2009Catherine NguyenActions
     alcl3.jpg
    No description
    38.9 kB17:57, 2 Mar 2009Catherine NguyenActions
     answer 3.jpg
    No description
    30.19 kB17:58, 2 Mar 2009Catherine NguyenActions
     answer 4.jpg
    No description
    45.28 kB17:51, 2 Mar 2009Catherine NguyenActions
     Benzene Brominationfinal (1).jpg
    No description
    37.11 kB16:34, 2 Mar 2009Catherine NguyenActions
     br+ copy.jpg
    No description
    35.59 kB15:16, 2 Mar 2009Catherine NguyenActions
     br+.jpg
    No description
    34.56 kB01:26, 2 Mar 2009Catherine NguyenActions
     electrophile (2).jpg
    No description
    38.83 kB16:27, 2 Mar 2009Catherine NguyenActions
     end copy (1).jpg
    No description
    43.63 kB15:45, 2 Mar 2009Catherine NguyenActions
     lg.jpg
    No description
    30.08 kB01:47, 2 Mar 2009Catherine NguyenActions
     no reaction (2).jpg
    No description
    30.99 kB15:52, 2 Mar 2009Catherine NguyenActions
     nuc (2).jpg
    No description
    34.06 kB16:32, 2 Mar 2009Catherine NguyenActions
     practice 1.jpg
    No description
    33.74 kB02:18, 2 Mar 2009Catherine NguyenActions
     practice 2.jpg
    No description
    29.81 kB02:22, 2 Mar 2009Catherine NguyenActions
     practice 3.jpg
    No description
    30.62 kB16:40, 2 Mar 2009Catherine NguyenActions
     Untitled.jpg
    No description
    4.4 kB01:15, 23 Feb 2009Catherine NguyenActions